SEO vs web design – which should Orlando businesses invest in first?

For many Orlando business owners, the question isn’t whether to invest in SEO or web design—it’s which to do first. Both impact your ability to attract leads, convert customers, and grow revenue. But the order matters, especially if you want the highest marketing ROI in Orlando.

Let’s break it down in plain English—without the fluff—so you can make the right call for your business.

Orlando demand snapshot

• Orlando welcomed 75,333,800 visitors in 2024 (+1.8% YoY). Visit Orlando
• Florida hosts ~3.3M small businesses (99.8% of all businesses; 40.9% of the workforce). Office of Advocacy

How web design impacts your growth

A website is your online storefront. If it’s slow, outdated, or confusing, visitors won’t stick around—no matter how good your marketing is. At Rathly, our small business web design Orlando team builds sites that don’t just look good, but guide visitors toward action.

A strong site offers:

• Fast loading speed that keeps people from bouncing.
• Mobile-friendly layouts for the 60%+ of visitors browsing on phones.
• Clear calls-to-action that drive form fills, calls, or sales.

As our design lead Antony Litovchenko says, every choice in design should lead visitors toward conversion—not just “look nice”. Without that foundation, your traffic—whether from ads or SEO—will struggle to convert into paying customers.

Passing Core Web Vitals is a clear bar for modern UX. Google defines ‘good’ as LCP ≤2.5s, INP ≤200ms, and CLS ≤0.1 at the 75th percentile. Sites that shave even 0.1s off mobile speed see measurable conversion lifts in controlled studies. If your hero image is the LCP (it is on most pages), compress and properly size it first. web.dev

How SEO drives sustainable leads

Small business SEO Orlando is about making your site easy to find when customers are searching. The right SEO strategy can get you in front of people at the exact moment they’re ready to buy.

At Rathly, we focus on website ranking Orlando using:

• On-page optimization for your target keywords.
• Local SEO to show up in Google Maps and “near me” searches.
• Content that answers your audience’s questions and builds trust.

Our SEO director Harry Laurel reminds business owners that “SEO is a long game. It’s the steady stream of qualified traffic that keeps your sales pipeline full month after month”.

Why local visibility matters in Orlando

• Google dominates U.S. search (~86% share), so optimizing for Google has the biggest upside. StatCounter Global Stats
• After a local mobile search, 76% of people visit a business within a day and 28% make a purchase. Google Business

Device behavior you’ll see in analytics

U.S. traffic share by device (Jul 2025)	Share	Why it matters
Desktop	49.47%	Don’t ignore desktop UX; it’s still half of traffic.
Mobile	48.15%	Service niches often skew higher on mobile; test forms and tap targets.
Tablet	2.38%	Low share; keep layouts responsive but don’t over-optimize here.

The “SEO vs web design” decision

Here’s the honest truth: if your current site is functional, loads quickly, and isn’t a total mess, start with SEO. You’ll drive traffic sooner and can refresh design later.

But if your site:

• Looks like it was built in 2010,
• Isn’t mobile-friendly,
• Or takes forever to load…

…then a redesign should be your first move. Otherwise, you’ll waste ad spend and SEO efforts sending traffic to a site that doesn’t convert.

Think of it like opening a new store—you wouldn’t run radio ads before the lights are on and shelves are stocked.

Decision matrix: what to do first

Condition (use your data)	How to check	Start with	Why
Fails CWV on key templates (home, services, top blog) or LCP > 2.5s, INP > 200ms, CLS > 0.1	PageSpeed Insights / CrUX (field data)	Web design/UX	Speed and stability directly affect bounce and conversions.
Mobile forms or booking flow have friction (rage-clicks, long TTFB, layout shifts)	Session replays, GA4 funnel, PSI diagnostics	Web design/UX	Fix conversion flow before adding traffic.
Site is functional and measurable, passes/near passes CWV on top pages	PSI + Search Console CWV report	SEO	Capture demand now; build compounding organic traffic.
Redesign or replatform is already planned in 0–3 months	Project roadmap	Web design + SEO migration plan	Protect current rankings during launch (redirects, mapping, testing).

Google’s guidance: involve SEO early when planning a redesign or new site. Google for Developers

SEO for new websites vs redesigns

For brand-new sites, the best approach is pairing web design for lead generation with foundational SEO from day one. That means building your site structure, pages, and content with search in mind, so you’re not redoing work later.

For redesigns, launch with an SEO migration plan. Otherwise, you risk losing the rankings and traffic you’ve built over the years.

Non-negotiables for redesigns and launches

• Map URLs and 301s; avoid orphaning top URLs. Google for Developers
• Audit CWV pre-launch with PSI (field + lab) and fix LCP/INP/CLS regressions. Google for Developers
• Verify in Google Search Console; monitor CWV and indexing after go-live. Google Help

If you’re launching or replatforming, loop SEO into planning. Map old→new URLs, set 301s, and test CWV before and after launch in PageSpeed Insights and Search Console to avoid traffic loss.

Our recommendation for Orlando businesses

If you need leads fast and your site is “good enough,” go SEO first. If your site can’t hold a visitor’s attention, go web design first. Either way, both will eventually be necessary if you want consistent growth.

At Rathly, we design sites that convert and build SEO strategies that rank. That way, you’re not forced to choose—you get a marketing system that works together.

Online marketing budgeting FAQs